Announcements

    Drinks

      ESG disclosure: gaps in DAX-40 GHG reporting show pitfalls for investors ahead of EU’s SFDR
      MONDAY, 15/08/2022 - Scope ESG Analysis GmbH
      Download PDF

      ESG disclosure: gaps in DAX-40 GHG reporting show pitfalls for investors ahead of EU’s SFDR

      Only half of companies in Germany’s benchmark DAX-40 stock market index have reported on more than four of 16 categories for indirect greenhouse gas emissions, presenting fund managers with a headache as new EU environmental regulations come into force.

      Download the report

      Fund managers are due to start ESG reporting, including indirect or so-called scope-3 GHG emissions, on their investment portfolios from next year when the EU’s Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) comes into force.

      But there is problem of regulatory timing. Larger companies themselves start reporting only in 2025 on their 2024 figures to comply with the EU’s Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD). Until that happens, DAX-40 disclosure shows how uneven the available data are.

      “The pressure on companies to report their CO2 emissions is steadily increasing - both through regulation and from investors,” says Bernhard Bartels, managing director at Scope ESG Analysis.

      “While most companies already comprehensively report their direct or scope-1 emissions and the emissions from energy consumption (scope-2), there are major differences in the reporting of indirect or scope-3 emissions,” Bartels says.

      “Inconsistent ESG reporting, by no means confined only to Germany’s larger companies, complicates the task for fund managers invested in these companies to make consistent decisions in putting together sustainability-linked portfolios,” he says.

      Seven DAX-40 companies have not reported on scope-3 GHG emissions at all. Six have reported on no more than two categories. Less than 50% have reported on the most relevant category “use of sold products” and only 26 provide information on the emissions in “purchased goods and services.” In addition, companies use different methodologies to account for their indirect emissions.

      “The results indicate that the complexity of capturing scope-3 emissions varies greatly between industries,” says Bartels.

      “Take banks and insurance companies which rely on the scope-3 emissions of their borrowers to report their own scope-3 emissions. Other sectors face the problem of complex and sometimes unstable supply chains that make it difficult to calculate emissions all along the value chain, with the textile industry a good example,” he says.

       

      Related news

      Show all
      European utilities: liquidity improves; Uniper nationalisation, guarantees show state support vital

      22/9/2022 Research

      European utilities: liquidity improves; Uniper ...

      Scope affirms BB-/Stable issuer credit rating on Hungarian tyre wholesaler MARSO

      21/9/2022 Rating announcement

      Scope affirms BB-/Stable issuer credit rating on Hungarian ...

      Scope affirms BB+ rating of Bikeleasing-Service GmbH & Co. KG, with Stable Outlook

      20/9/2022 Rating announcement

      Scope affirms BB+ rating of Bikeleasing-Service GmbH & Co. ...

      Secured Green Bonds incentivise covered bond issuers to increase market risk

      20/9/2022 Research

      Secured Green Bonds incentivise covered bond issuers to ...

      Scope affirms Totens Sparebank's issuer rating of A- with Stable Outlook

      19/9/2022 Rating announcement

      Scope affirms Totens Sparebank's issuer rating of A- with ...

      Webinar: Italy: Credit outlook after the elections

      19/9/2022 Research

      Webinar: Italy: Credit outlook after the elections