Announcements

    Drinks

      South Africa: governance risk and rising debt challenge credit ratings
      MONDAY, 20/03/2023 - Scope Ratings GmbH
      Download PDF

      South Africa: governance risk and rising debt challenge credit ratings

      The weak governance behind the crisis in South Africa’s energy sector, which is contributing to sluggish growth and rising government debt, looks set to endure beyond elections due in 2024, with implications for South Africa’s credit ratings.

      By Dennis Shen, Director and Thomas Gillet, Associate Director, Sovereign Ratings

      We forecast GDP growth of 0.8% this year, down from 2.0% in 2022 and below the South African economy’s 1.5% potential annual rate, before a slow rebound to 1.8% next year. Years of weak economic growth have ensured GDP per capita remains near where it was in the early 1980s as structural economic bottlenecks, such as inadequate electricity generation, hinder wealth creation.

      South Africa (BB+/Stable) can expect only modest near-term relief from the chronic electricity crisis with the declaration of a national state of disaster and appointment of a new electricity minister in the latest cabinet reshuffle. The cost of the now daily blackouts may be running at around USD 50m a day, according to the South African Reserve Bank.

      The government’s latest conditional debt relief for Eskom, South Africa’s state-owned electricity utility, covers more than three quarters of its net borrowings of ZAR 423bn (USD 23bn) – equivalent to 5.9% of GDP – but will make it harder for the government to meet its objectives of stabilising public debt.

      Figure 1. South Africa’s public debt burden rises under strain of Eskom rescue
      % of GDP

      Source: National Treasury (South Africa), Scope Ratings

      Structural fiscal deficits, contingent liabilities point to rising debt burden

      Government debt will exceed 80% of GDP in 2025, above the government forecast for it to peak at nearly 74%, having risen from 69% in 2021 (Figure 1). The government had previously forecast debt-to-GDP would peak at 71% in fiscal year 2022.

      Weak governance limits the capacity to address some of the most pressing challenges such as rigid labour markets dampening productivity and economic growth. Rising interest payments, the rand’s depreciation and contingent liabilities also explain the rising debt trajectory. Net interest payments will rise to 28.3% of general government revenues by 2027, up from 13.4% in 2019. The government’s budget deficit will widen to an average of 7.2% of GDP between 2024 and 2027 from 5.8% this year.

      Eskom is likely to need more state support, further pushing up state borrowing, for two reasons. First, the company, a pillar of the South African economy, faces hefty costs associated with the energy transition considering coal accounts for 70% of energy use and 85% of electricity generation.

      The second reason is Eskom’s poor record (Figure 2). The utility has received multiple public bailouts since 2008, amounting to ZAR 263.4bn, without materially improving its underlying performance, due in part to financial crime that the National Treasury has identified as one of the main risks for the economic outlook.

      Easing Eskom’s debt burden requires profound change by improving governance and cracking down on corruption and theft, but inaction is a danger given vested interests in the status quo.

      Furthermore, the utility’s challenges are common to other public-sector entities. The government may have to assume some of the ZAR 56.3bn in debt (0.8% of GDP) owed by municipalities to Eskom in addition to supporting other state-owned enterprises.

      Figure 2. Multiple Eskom bailouts have failed to boost electricity generation capacity
      Index (LHS), GWh (RHS)

      Source: National Treasury (South Africa), Scope Ratings

      Military exercises with Russia, FATF grey listing exemplify weak governance

      Confidence that the current South African government can address governance weaknesses is waning. One reason is the diplomatic rapprochement with Russia despite the United States’ crack-down on Western sanctions evasion – the two BRICS countries recently held joint military exercises with China. Another is the decision by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) to list South Africa as a “jurisdiction under increased monitoring”.

      South Africa’s inclusion on the FATF grey list reflects a vulnerability of the financial system, otherwise one of the country’s main credit strengths, in line with conclusions of the State Capture Commission on corruption and fraud in the public sector.

      Further crystallisation of liabilities on the government balance sheet together with governance risk and poor sentiment in financial markets could impair debt sustainability and exert downside pressure on the sovereign’s credit ratings. Scope’s next review of South Africa’s ratings is on 21 April.

      Access all Scope rating & research reports on ScopeOne, Scope’s digital marketplace, which includes API solutions for Scope’s credit rating feed, providing institutional clients access to Scope’s growing number of corporate, bank, sovereign and public sector ratings.

      Related news

      Show all
      France: higher-than-expected 2023 deficit tests ability to achieve fiscal targets

      28/3/2024 Research

      France: higher-than-expected 2023 deficit tests ability to ...

      Georgia ratings constrained by geopolitical sensitivities, institutional risks

      27/3/2024 Research

      Georgia ratings constrained by geopolitical sensitivities, ...

      Scope has completed a monitoring review for the Kingdom of Denmark

      22/3/2024 Monitoring note

      Scope has completed a monitoring review for the Kingdom of ...

      Scope affirms the sovereign rating of Japan at A and revises Outlook to Stable

      22/3/2024 Rating announcement

      Scope affirms the sovereign rating of Japan at A and revises ...

      Scope affirms Spain’s credit ratings at A-, revises the Outlook to Positive

      22/3/2024 Rating announcement

      Scope affirms Spain’s credit ratings at A-, revises the ...

      Scope has completed a monitoring review for the Kingdom of Norway

      22/3/2024 Monitoring note

      Scope has completed a monitoring review for the Kingdom of Norway